by Westwood52 » 31 Jul 2020 12:29
by Hound » 31 Jul 2020 13:46
by Nameless » 31 Jul 2020 13:49
Hound Swift 6? ie same as McCleary?
enough said
by NewCorkSeth » 31 Jul 2020 14:10
Westwood52 Rafael 6 Few major howlers;but that nagging feeling that he should have saved a few.Poor short and long kicks;a constant problem.
Yids 7 When he played.Season ruined by two major injuries.Physical and aggressive ,but lacking in finesse.A good buy however.
Gunter 6 After a couple of poor previous seasons,was back to average this season.Standing off his winger still a problem.
Osho 7 Very promising.
Obita 5 Still a good crosser;but two bad injuries have left him unable to put in much of an influence in games.
Richards 6 Targeted early season,then hit good form;then dropped off post lockdown.
Blackett 6 Better,but still prone to lapses of concentration.
Moore 5 Bit iffy really.Had his moments,then let himself down.
Miazga 5 Bad injury,stupid sending off.More influential last year.
Morrison 6 Started with three or four goals against him,but was reasonably solid thereafter.Limited mobility however.
McIntire 5 Great against Luton,but needs to beef up over the break,too easily bossed.
Rino 6 Started with second season syndrome,but then got back into it as the season progressed.Limited however,but strong at driving at the opposition.
Pele 6 Again injury ruined season.Some games he did look top class.Sorry to see him go.
Swift 6 TBF he kept offering himself when he was completely off his game.I really don’t think he is good enough for the Prem.
Ejaria 6 There is a great player in there somewhere,but he needs to be more consistent and find a pass rather than try to beat the third man.We are so much more dangerous with him.
Olise 8 Apart from his shooting,which needs to improve we have got someone special here.
Macca 6 Occasionally showed glimpses of his best days.
Masika 5 Never really got a chance,but looks a one trick pony.
Baldock 5 Towards the end of the season,veered towards a 6.Rarely used properly.
Meite 7 You can’t argue with 17 goals can you.Bit of a bull in a china shop though.Will he get better?
Jao 6 Injury ruined season.
Puskas 6 Rarely injured.A return of 13 goals probably fair enough.I think it would be a mistake to sell him.I have this nagging feeling he could be very sharp next season.
NewCorkSeth I'm amazed anyone read that. Bit of spacing would be nice. Easier on the eyes.
by Westwood52 » 31 Jul 2020 14:47
Old Man AndrewsNewCorkSeth I'm amazed anyone read that. Bit of spacing would be nice. Easier on the eyes.
I saw the first rating and comment for Rafael and stopped. Thick as mince.
Westwood52Old Man AndrewsNewCorkSeth I'm amazed anyone read that. Bit of spacing would be nice. Easier on the eyes.
I saw the first rating and comment for Rafael and stopped. Thick as mince.
Can’t tell you how disappointed I would have been,if you hadn’t reacted.You need a course refresher,though.
by Ascotexgunner » 31 Jul 2020 21:19
Old Man AndrewsNewCorkSeth I'm amazed anyone read that. Bit of spacing would be nice. Easier on the eyes.
I saw the first rating and comment for Rafael and stopped. Thick as mince.
by AthleticoSpizz » 31 Jul 2020 21:23
by Zip » 31 Jul 2020 21:52
Westwood52 Rafael 6 Few major howlers;but that nagging feeling that he should have saved a few.Poor short and long kicks;a constant problem.
Yids 7 When he played.Season ruined by two major injuries.Physical and aggressive ,but lacking in finesse.A good buy however.
Gunter 6 After a couple of poor previous seasons,was back to average this season.Standing off his winger still a problem.
Osho 7 Very promising.
Obita 5 Still a good crosser;but two bad injuries have left him unable to put in much of an influence in games.
Richards 6 Targeted early season,then hit good form;then dropped off post lockdown.
Blackett 6 Better,but still prone to lapses of concentration.
Moore 5 Bit iffy really.Had his moments,then let himself down.
Miazga 5 Bad injury,stupid sending off.More influential last year.
Morrison 6 Started with three or four goals against him,but was reasonably solid thereafter.Limited mobility however.
McIntire 5 Great against Luton,but needs to beef up over the break,too easily bossed.
Rino 6 Started with second season syndrome,but then got back into it as the season progressed.Limited however,but strong at driving at the opposition.
Pele 6 Again injury ruined season.Some games he did look top class.Sorry to see him go.
Swift 6 TBF he kept offering himself when he was completely off his game.I really don’t think he is good enough for the Prem.
Ejaria 6 There is a great player in there somewhere,but he needs to be more consistent and find a pass rather than try to beat the third man.We are so much more dangerous with him.
Olise 8 Apart from his shooting,which needs to improve we have got someone special here.
Macca 6 Occasionally showed glimpses of his best days.
Masika 5 Never really got a chance,but looks a one trick pony.
Baldock 5 Towards the end of the season,veered towards a 6.Rarely used properly.
Meite 7 You can’t argue with 17 goals can you.Bit of a bull in a china shop though.Will he get better?
Jao 6 Injury ruined season.
Puskas 6 Rarely injured.A return of 13 goals probably fair enough.I think it would be a mistake to sell him.I have this nagging feeling he could be very sharp next season.
by windermereROYAL » 31 Jul 2020 21:58
by Zip » 31 Jul 2020 22:00
windermereROYAL Pusk(c)as got 14.
AthleticoSpizz Why the need to throw out the insultS ‘OMA’ ?
Another thread needlessly wrecked
by AthleticoSpizz » 31 Jul 2020 22:07
by Westwood52 » 31 Jul 2020 23:34
Old Man AndrewsWestwood52Old Man Andrews I saw the first rating and comment for Rafael and stopped. Thick as mince.
Can’t tell you how disappointed I would have been,if you hadn’t reacted.You need a course refresher,though.
Thanks, for, reinforcing, my, point.
by Gunny Fishcake » 06 Aug 2020 08:02
Old Man AndrewsAthleticoSpizz Why the need to throw out the insultS ‘OMA’ ?
Another thread needlessly wrecked
Because he is thick.
Go away, do one.
by Royalwaster » 06 Aug 2020 08:25
by Westwood52 » 06 Aug 2020 09:54
NamelessHound Swift 6? ie same as McCleary?
enough said
Masika same as McIntyre , Osho 2 higher than McIntyre ?
I’m not sure a ranking like this makes sense.
by South Coast Royal » 06 Aug 2020 10:40
Royalwaster Agree ratings are rather off, but shame others had to destroy an interesting debate with name calling. Surely, it does not make sense to rate Olise as our highest rated player given he did not score a single goal and did not get many assists ... our top rated players despite their faults have to be Swift, Rafael, Meite, Pele, Morrison given their overall contribution. But none of them were great. You could rate Olise maybe as an 8 in a separate category of 'hot prospects' but under overall contribution he's a 5.
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Farnham Royal, From Despair To Where?, Google [Bot], SCIAG, Vision and 212 guests