AthleticoSpizz Pukkis’ goal was ruled offside because of his hand being in an offside position...no?
Can this crap...just keep the goal line decisions
by John Madejski's Wallet » 30 Dec 2019 10:42
John Madejski's Wallet Had there been no VAR the oppo would not have complained about the goal if they'd seen the freeze frame. Therefore its a total VAR fail
Same with the Wolves one. I don't think they should use the computer generated lines for an offside. A simple eyeballing of the freeze frame by the VAR ref like we used to see on MotD/Sky highlights. If its not obviously offside by the naked eye, then the goal should stand. THAT should be the margin of error
by Victor Meldrew » 30 Dec 2019 11:34
by Snowflake Royal » 30 Dec 2019 12:54
SanguineAthleticoSpizz Pukkis’ goal was ruled offside because of his hand being in an offside position...no?
Can this crap...just keep the goal line decisions
Armpit. Can't score with your arm.
My issue with the Pukki one is that he is offside because he is leaning more than the defender. His feet are actually clearly onside vs. that defender, but because Pukki has started to run harder, his upper body has moved marginally beyond his marker.
I find this ridiculous.
by Victor Meldrew » 30 Dec 2019 12:57
Sanguine Fwiw I thought VAR worked just fine at the World Cup - but what I don't really understand is what different 'protocols' were followed there. I don't recall all these drawing lines on screens in Russia.
Some interesting* stats from Italy from its first full season of use, 18/19.
346 games
1,736 checks (5.1 per game)
105 decisions changed (1 every 3.3 games)
17 errors made (incorrect decisions retained, or correct decisions overturned)
6.05% error rate in 17/18, 0.98% error rate (those 17 errors) in 18/19.
And the bits I found really interesting...
8.8% fewer fouls
19.3% fewer protests
43.0% fewer simulations
by Royal Rother » 30 Dec 2019 14:41
by Franchise FC » 30 Dec 2019 20:06
by Snowflake Royal » 30 Dec 2019 23:32
Franchise FC According to IFAB the VAR implementation in the PL has NOT followed the ruling body guidelines on ‘clear and obvious’.
Seems like the PL referees have taken their own initiative and are trying to make the technology do something that it can’t currently do.
NO SHIT SHERLOCK
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/lawmakers-to-issue-guidance-that-var-should-only-overrule-clear-and-obvious-offside-errors/ar-BBYsOBA?li=BBoPWjP
by From Despair To Where? » 31 Dec 2019 02:38
Snowflake RoyalFranchise FC According to IFAB the VAR implementation in the PL has NOT followed the ruling body guidelines on ‘clear and obvious’.
Seems like the PL referees have taken their own initiative and are trying to make the technology do something that it can’t currently do.
NO SHIT SHERLOCK
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/lawmakers-to-issue-guidance-that-var-should-only-overrule-clear-and-obvious-offside-errors/ar-BBYsOBA?li=BBoPWjP
Or someone is trying to make it fail.
From Despair To Where?Snowflake RoyalFranchise FC According to IFAB the VAR implementation in the PL has NOT followed the ruling body guidelines on ‘clear and obvious’.
Seems like the PL referees have taken their own initiative and are trying to make the technology do something that it can’t currently do.
NO SHIT SHERLOCK
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/lawmakers-to-issue-guidance-that-var-should-only-overrule-clear-and-obvious-offside-errors/ar-BBYsOBA?li=BBoPWjP
Or someone is trying to make it fail.
Which won't work because if everywhere else is implementing it correctly and it's doing the job it was designed to do, FIFA will just dismiss the EPL as a statistical anomaly and tell the FA to sort it's shit out, and the concept of FIFA telling anyone to sort their shit out is pretty fcuking ironic.
by From Despair To Where? » 31 Dec 2019 09:24
From Despair To Where? I though you were bound by some sort of non disclosure regarding the finer details of VAR?
by Victor Meldrew » 31 Dec 2019 11:24
Franchise FC According to IFAB the VAR implementation in the PL has NOT followed the ruling body guidelines on ‘clear and obvious’.
Seems like the PL referees have taken their own initiative and are trying to make the technology do something that it can’t currently do.
NO SHIT SHERLOCK
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/lawmakers-to-issue-guidance-that-var-should-only-overrule-clear-and-obvious-offside-errors/ar-BBYsOBA?li=BBoPWjP
Victor MeldrewFranchise FC According to IFAB the VAR implementation in the PL has NOT followed the ruling body guidelines on ‘clear and obvious’.
Seems like the PL referees have taken their own initiative and are trying to make the technology do something that it can’t currently do.
NO SHIT SHERLOCK
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/lawmakers-to-issue-guidance-that-var-should-only-overrule-clear-and-obvious-offside-errors/ar-BBYsOBA?li=BBoPWjP
I blame Brexit.
Whereas the rest of Europe use VAR to look at "clear and obvious" we do it our way just to be oxf*rd different.
by Franchise FC » 01 Jan 2020 13:38
genome
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 70 guests