Would you resign Sidwell if we went up?

[Archie's penalty]

?

[Svlad Cjelli]

Why would we? Turning the click back never works.

(qv Coppell's desperation loan signing of Kitson & Little)

[Archie's penalty]

His performances recently with Fulham have been very impressive. Simplez.

[bigmike]

Nope not when we could go for Messi

Would prefer to get Sig back

[Optimist]

I'd prefer Sig too, and Doyle if Wolves go down.

[Archie's penalty]

Doyle back would be superb.

[super darren caskey]

Doyle back would be superb.

Indeed +1

[Sarah Star]

McDermot said, at one of the fans' forums, that the only one from the Championship winning side of 2005/6 he'd have back was Sidwell.

[Gordons Cumming]

Why would we? Turning the click back never works.

(qv Coppell's desperation loan signing of Kitson & Little)

Sometimes turning the clock back does though..................

[Rex]

Probably due to his playing a superb season before going out on a free, unlike other prima donnas who did the opposite.

[Cookie]

TBH I voted NO. But I remember at a recent Star-forum Brian was asked which of the last promotion squad he'd have in his team if he could choose and he answered without hesitation - Sidwell


EDIT - whoops, just noticed Sarah said what I just said.

[Row Z Royal]

Why would we? Turning the click back never works.

(qv Coppell's desperation loan signing of Kitson & Little)

Sometimes turning the clock back does though..................

It did tomorrow, that's for sure.

[Sarah Star]

TBH I voted NO. But I remember at a recent Star-forum Brian was asked which of the last promotion squad he'd have in his team if he could choose and he answered without hesitation - Sidwell


EDIT - whoops, just noticed Sarah said what I just said.

Great minds, Cookie...

That was before we lost Siggie and got Leigertwood though.

[Fox Talbot]

I just think Sid's become a bit too big / rich / London for us now. He'd expect to be the captain / main man etc. Also he's done it at Reading - up to 8th.

The ones I'd get back are:

Gylfi
Simon Cox
Ryan Bertrand

Young enough and hopefully have some feel for the club and rapport with our younger players.

There's no way I expect we could afford Doyle and he deserves better than another Prem struggle.

[Z175]

Doyle, Shorey, Sidwell and Sigurdsson would guarantee survival

[Mr Angry]

I'll say it, as no-one else has done....


WCBAP.

[wolsey]

I just think Sid's become a bit too big / rich / London for us now. He'd expect to be the captain / main man etc. Also he's done it at Reading - up to 8th.

The ones I'd get back are:

Gylfi
Simon Cox
Ryan Bertrand

Young enough and hopefully have some feel for the club and rapport with our younger players.

There's no way I expect we could afford Doyle and he deserves better than another Prem struggle.

Agree with all that - every single word (sorry still don't feel comfortable +1ing)

[NR_Royal]

I can't see us spending more than £20k p/w on any player tbh, and I imagine Sidwell is on around £40k p/w. So no.

[The Goat was fed]

It's a weird one this...in theory I'd have them all back - but it just so rarely works that I wouldn't have any of them back. The two players I would have most liked to have "come back" the season after we got relegated was Kitson and Little, it happened...be careful what I wish for.

[royalsroyalsroyals92]

McDermot said, at one of the fans' forums, that the only one from the Championship winning side of 2005/6 he'd have back was Sidwell.

Did he mention any particular reason for this?
Doyle back would be great but better stop dreaming!