by muirinho »
21 Nov 2017 09:30
21 Nov 2017 09:30
Mr Optimist wrote:
That said, the tribalism and passion is a lot of what makes the atmosphere at football, and would that go without segregating fans. God only knows all other fun at football is being sucked out.
I don't think hurling and football (Gaelic) in Ireland, OR Rugby (here or in Ireland) lack tribalism and passion. You don't need to segregate fans for that. However there are pluses and minuses with the two approaches.
From my experience of watching hurling and football, because fans aren't segregated, people make more of an effort to show their support visibly- if you don't have home and away ends, you need to make yourself stand out so your team knows you're there. So there are lots and lots of flags. More of a spectacle.
But - you don't get the chants you get with soccer, because you don't have an area where they can start.
I'd keep the segregation during the game - I think it's part of the tradition. But separation before and after matches is a bit silly I think. One of the things I like about the Royal Rendezvous is the fact that home and away supporters are mingling quite naturally, and without even a hint of trouble, before the game.