Reading FC Match Report: 2016/2017 Season - Championship
READING 2 BRIGHTON 2
Reading: J Swift (2), P McShane (59)
Brighton: J van den Berg (og 8), A Knockaert (46)
It took the Royals a mere two minutes to breach an Albion defence which had not conceded in their opening four fixtures of the season. Beerens won a free kick wide on the right and Swift whipped in an inviting cross which eluded everyone and curled inside the far post. It was just the start Reading needed following two successive away defeats last week. There may have been a few raised eyebrows when Jaap Stam opted to retain the same starting eleven form the previous two games, but his decision was vindicated with convincing performance against a strong Albion side. On the balance of play and chances created Reading could reasonably argue they deserved all three points.
The early lead was soon cancelled out as Albion stormed back and Van den Berg headed into his own net from an Albion corner in the eighth minute. There was a hint of some pushing but it was essentially a consequence poor defending. Van Berg somehow found himself facing his own goal having to clear a ball dropping in the six yards box which Al Habsi should really have claimed. The goal took the wind out their sails but Reading soon settled and began to dominate possession passing the ball around comfortably at the back and treading passes through midfield and getting at the Albion defence. Jaap Stam's influence was becoming increasingly apparent as his players looked comfortable in possession, picked out passes, and moved into spaces all over the pitch. Chances fell to Kermorgant who had one effort blocked, a low drive which skimmed wide from the edge of the box and a well-executed volley on the stroke of half time which also flew just past the post.
Within a minute of the re-start Reading found themselves a goal down. McShane switched off (as did the rest of the back four) and let his man get behind him to pull the ball back for Knockaert who found himself in acres of space to drive the ball low into the net past Al Habsi. The Royals were in no mood to roll over and re-established their grip on the game although now they had to contend with the threat of Albion counter attacks and some appalling refereeing. Kermorgant beat Stockdale with a well-timed header only to see his effort bounce back off the bar. Reading scored the equaliser they deserved just on the hour. McCleary, who is already looking a better player under Stam, cut back an excellent ball to McShane in the box. The quality of the pass enabled the Reading centre back to finish with a crisp first time strike. Reading looked to more likely side to win the game and were denied by a dubious decision when Gunter was brought down by a challenge which looked to just inside the box. Referee Jones gradually lost his grip on the game and made a string of really poor decisions, notably ignoring an ugly lunge on Williams and an elbow to Kermorgant’s head. Kermogant dished out his own retribution and received a yellow card shortly after. Brighton hung on and Kermorgant nearly hit the winner with a superbly executed overhead kick which Stockdale somehow pushed away.
With time running out substitute Hemed’s sharp turn took him away from the Reading defence leaving Van den Berg the option of allowing him a run on goal or a ‘tactical’ foul. His choice resulted in a second yellow card and Brighton free kick which came to nothing. Reading fully deserved their point and can feel confident about their chances this season if they continue to play with such enterprise. Beerens, Van den Berg and Swift are all good footballers and Williams and McCleary are clearly improving under the new manager and his coaching staff. There was a positive mood amongst the home fans after the final whistle today, and rightly so, they had more than matched one of the strongest sides in the league.
John Wells
Post Match Fans' Opinion
windermereROYAL
» 20 Aug 2016 17:31
Hugely encouraging.
Royal Ginger
» 20 Aug 2016 17:48
Nobody really stood out as excellent but almost everybody was pretty solid. No argument with VDB's second yellow, but the first was bullshit if it's not enforced across the board. Kermorgant should have gone at the end.
McShane looks awful with the ball at his feet but I think part of the problem is Evans not looking for space and giving him an outlet.
Good game, enjoyed it.
John Madejski's Wallet
» 20 Aug 2016 18:01
Once we stopped with the really aimless passing at the back and mixed it up more, the game really opened up. McCleary had them in his pocket, Kermogant put in a right shift too.
As a real lover of Williams over the last couple of seasons, I think he's now our weak link. With Evans and Swift in there now, he needs to sort himself and get a purpose as I'm not sure of his role.
sandman
» 20 Aug 2016 18:13
Murray as mouthy as ever but did unlike Van Den Berg didn't get booked for it. Steve "I'll definitely sign a contract for 20 grand a week, no wait 25k, no wait 30k, no I had no intention of signing a contract and I'm off to Chelsea" Sidwell would have had to get out a machete and hack people to death to receive so much as a talking to by the awful ref. Norwood reception was interesting. Rosenior won't be blowing kisses to the opposition fans again any time soon.
Overall positive, less messing around at the back with a better tempo.
Royality creeps In
» 20 Aug 2016 18:35
They had one decent player in their number 11. The rest were pretty average at best.
Highlight for me was seeing that whinging twat Rosenier taken out. How he even earns a living as a professional is beyond me.
Justice for the verbals he was giving the East stand in the first half.
Shame to see Sidders clogging around. A shadow of his former self
Still onwards and upwards on that showing
Lower West
» 20 Aug 2016 18:42
With Moore a certainty to start. VDB can move into midfield. A Swift\Evans\VDB midfield on paper looks the best we've we've had for some years. As all 3 are technically good.
Thought Yann had a good game today. However would prefer someone upfront with real pace. To give an alternative outlet. The front three can then alternate.
Weakest link today was Obita. Exposed for lack of pace.
Barcelona Blue
» 20 Aug 2016 19:11
Overall a cracking game against a good Brighton side who will be up there at the end of the season
Habsi- 8 solid enough , didnt do anything wrong
Obita - 5 looked a bit flappy and something´s not right , he doesnt like this new system
McShane-8 Good, nice to see him get one
Joey VdB- 9 Reading´s man of the match for me, I thought he was superb, tackled, good in the air, good passing, shame about the argueing for the first yellow and the red was a profesional foul, with five minutes to go why not,
Gunter- 7.5- OK, good no probs
Beerens- 7.5 tricky, good
Swift- 8.5 very, very good player there, I hope were pushing for the prem by at least the end of next season otherwise we´ll lose him
Mcleary - 7.5 same as Beerens
Danny Williams- 7.5 - huffed and puffed , did OK but needs to run of the ball as well to give defenders more options
Evans 8- quite calm and composed, nothing amazing but he could turn out to be a really good player in time, was surprised
Kermit 7- good header and nice bycycle kick but we need more than that, the wingers are doing there job but hes not quite good enough
Man of the match- joey
Ref- I would never mention the ref but he was APPALING
sat in the east stand , good atmosphere from both sets of fans
Value for money- 9
Overall verdict, if we are going to play around at the back, then the midfielders need to give the defenders more options by running more off the ball, promising and the beginnings of something good
Maneki Neko
» 20 Aug 2016 19:25
I really like joey. Got sent off and scored o.g but still had a good game.
Beerens also decent.
Mcleary had a good game.
Evans tidy, Swift good but faded.
Mcshane got beaten for pace a couple of times(including for the goal.) as did Obita. If we can sort the defensive lapses/concentration issues we will be fine.
Lol at moaning about rosenior. He did it all with a smile on his face and got pelters for the whole first half. Fair play for playing along, pantomime style, I say
SMF
» 20 Aug 2016 19:54
I personally think Rosenior is a decent player. Almost certainly saved a goal with a last ditch tackle on Kermorgant in the first half. Didn't see to much wrong with what he did today, got verbals from the crowd so blew a kiss back, not exactly Matt Mills-esque...
On the game, think we could have won and played well in parts. Shame that we didn't get a foot on the game after scoring so early, took around 20 minutes to finally start playing again. Also a shame that they didn't come out for the start of the second half and conceded a really sloppy goal. Responded well and McShane made up for his part in the second Brighton goal with a decent finish to equalise. Obita needs to do more. Kermorgant was better but it's clear we need another striker. Man of the match for me goes to McCleary, hopefully he can stay fit.
AthleticoSpizz
» 20 Aug 2016 20:17
Lot of pcunts enjoying that on twatter too.
It was a shocking tackle, could've got a red - I hope Rosenoir is OKtackle was late, but believe it or not, there wasn't that much hard-core contact....more than likely Rosie turned an ankle or something.
Thought he was ok for them, but give us a Knockaert (#11) please MrThai, he was awesome.
Nameless
» 20 Aug 2016 20:52
From my seatin the North it looked inside.
The ref had no idea, the Lino gave it outside despite not having a great view and only gave it after the ref had blown for the foul.
To be honest if the officials were not able to see clearly then they did the right thing. But if they were not able to see clearly then maybe basket weaving would be a better way to spend their Saturday than messing up other people's football.
Westwood52
» 20 Aug 2016 20:55
Brighton are very good-but have too many old men to be serious contenders. They had us on toast for twenty minutes around about when they got their 1st goal-then we had them under the cosh for about twenty minutes 2nd half; however soon as Macca and Beerens tired we fell away-time to bring on the cavalry, Jap at that point.
Habsi 6: Not much to do-couple of flaps-one poor clearance 1st half.
Gunts 6: Normal day at the Office really.
Obita 4: Tough afternoon; against their best player-just about survived. Quinn at LB midweek ?
Joey 7: One great tackle 2nd half-world class-but then took one for the team late on.
McShane 6: Ran ragged & looked clumsy but redeemed his performance with great goal.
Evans 6: Didn't reach any great heights of performance , but once again nice & tidy.
Williams 5: Bit of a mixed bag really-gave the ball away too often-but dangerous once he gets up a head of steam.
Swift 7: Another classy performance; without doing anything special.
Macca 8: MOM-tired late on , but back to his near best.
Kermit 7: His best game for a while-looked a threat and unlucky not to score.
Beerens 7: Pretty good-some nice touches.
Quinn: Looked a bit rusty-not surprising.
Mendes :Hmm-I reserve judgement-early days.
Finally the Ref & East Stand Lino-both were appalling .Players are not allowed to speak to them-but it must be so frustrating for the players-to try and earn a living with this standard of officiating-the Referee Panel have to do better somehow.
The Ref in particular was the worst we have had for a couple of seasons. I know its a tough job-but Brighton's first was clearly a foul & equally it was clearly a Reading pen 2nd half. A number of Brighton players escaped yellow cards for similar offences for which Reading players were booked & TBF Kermit's late lunge was a clear Red -as was The Brighton's players reaction to the McShane foul 2nd half.
End of rant-after an enjoyable afternoon.
marlowuk
» 20 Aug 2016 21:13
The first half was a half of two halves! After we scored in the 2nd minute we hardly got out of our own half for 20 minutes during which time Joey VdB equalised for them. Thereafter we took the game to them with McCleary particularly looking dangerous.
The second half was more open and fairly even although Habsi was never really tested whereas Stockdale made some excellent saves from Kermy and we had one effort cleared off the line. Knockaert was fast, clever and a handful for Obita but I thought Jordan did OK against him.
A few other random observations ...
Sidwell was a shadow of his former self
The booing of Norwood was unnecessary - he has been a good servant to the club
The Brighton fans outsang us
The Ref was very poor
Hampshire Royal
» 20 Aug 2016 21:57
A lot of people have posted that Brighton were good and that the ref was poor. It's true that Brighton played well, but what will get them in the top 6 this season is the clever way they managed to fool the ref by diving and falling over and by pulling and pushing the Reading players. They did all this on the blind side of the ref. VdB was pushed for their first. and was justifiably upset by this, but shouldn't have badgered the ref, which ultimately led to him being sent off. Kermorgant was belted by Rosenior, which the ref didn't see. I would rather see my team lose fairly than win like Brighton do!! Even Sidwell was acting like a thug, which disappointed me!!
Highlight of the game, for me, was seeing Kermorgant running faster than I've ever seen him to get revenge on Rosenior.
The Jaap Stam style is looking really good and all it needs to become perfect is for a few of the players to have just a little more self-confidence.
Royal Ginger
» 20 Aug 2016 22:08
2 seasons he was here for, 2 seasons of mediocre football we've had. who jumped ship as soon as someone came in for him. How was he a good servant?!
Need I remind anyone how many corners it took for us to score last year.. And the percentage he would have taken.
I disagree about how good he was but that's besides the point. Even if he was mediocre I don't think anyone could realistically say he didn't put in any effort. Ignoring his arrival as 'just another player' would be fine, but booing him suggests he did something bad, which he didn't. It was a bizarre reaction.
Nameless
» 20 Aug 2016 22:11
Kermogant's foul was not great, but there were several other incidents which were as bad. Disappointed that Sidwell seemed to think it was ok to tackle any time within 3 seconds of a player releasing the ball...
Nameless
» 20 Aug 2016 22:12
2 seasons he was here for, 2 seasons of mediocre football we've had. who jumped ship as soon as someone came in for him. How was he a good servant?!
Need I remind anyone how many corners it took for us to score last year.. And the percentage he would have taken.
I disagree about how good he was but that's besides the point. Even if he was mediocre I don't think anyone could realistically say he didn't put in any effort. Ignoring his arrival as 'just another player' would be fine, but booing him suggests he did something bad, which he didn't. It was a bizarre reaction.
There wasn't much booing though, the applause drowned it out. I suspect the booing was down more to Norwood's rather two faced 'message' to us sent via GetReading. Better to say nothing than insult our intelligence Ollie.
Match Stats
Full Time: 2-2
Half Time: 1-1
Attendance: 16781
Referee: M Jones
[More]
Teams
Reading:
A Al Habsi, C Gunter, J Obita, J van den Berg, P McShane, R Beerens (J Cooper, 89), G McCleary (J Mendes, 87), J Swift (S Quinn, 82), Y Kermorgant, D Williams, G Evans.
Subs not used: Y Meite, T Watson, C Harriott, A Jaakkola.
Brighton:
D Stockdale, Bruno, L Dunk, G Bong, L Rosenior, A Knockaert, S Sidwell, J Skalak (J Murphy, 76), B Kayal, S Baldock (O Norwood, 68), G Murray (T Hemed, 86).
Subs not used: K Lua Lua, N Maenpaa, B White, R Ince.
Bookings / Red Cards
Reading: J van den Berg, Y Kermorgant, D Williams.
Sent Off: J van den Berg (90 mins)
Brighton: L Dunk, G Bong
Championship on 20 August 2016
This Championship game took place 3498 days ago in the 2016/2017 season.

