Reading FC Match Report: 2017/2018 Season - Championship
READING 2 ASTON VILLA 1
Reading: G Whelan (og 49), M Barrow (55)
Aston Villa: C Hourihane (87)
The Royals chalked up their first Championship victory of the season against an expensively assembled experienced and talented Villa side with a dominant performance which was not reflected in the scoreline. Reading scored twice in the space of six minutes early in the second half and looked to be cruising comfortably to a deserved win until the visitors pulled a goal back four minutes from time through Houirihane. It was an anxious final few minutes for the home fans but anything other than a Reading victory would have been a travesty.
Villa barely touched the ball in the opening thirty minutes as Reading played the patient possession football which Jaap Stam has been developing so effectively over the past year. The difference this in this performance compared to last season was the way players throughout the team were willing to make themselves available to receive a pass, remain composed on the ball and make good decisions about where and when to deliver their passes. With new players added to the squad with pace and good touch Reading were able to open up Villa’s defence with intricate passing and movement. All that was missing was the finish.
It was Villa however who might have scored first in the fifth minute when the ball broke kindly to give Green a run at an unprotected Manone who spread himself to deny the Villa forward. Swift and Barrow fired in long range shots which had Villa ‘Keeper Johnstone scrambling to reach but flew just wide. Kelly and Popa had shots blocked, and McShane mistimed a free header from a Kelly corner. Reading came closest to opening the scoring when Gunter found Popa on the edge of the box who hit a powerful shot which Johnstone did well to keep out.
Barrow and Kelly had chances to early in the second half but when the opening goal came there was element of luck about it and was ultimately credited as an own goal to Whelan. Popa, released by Swift just inside the Villa half, sped away from the Villa defence before hitting a cross which hit Whelan and looped over Johnstone who clawed it away but clearly from behind the goal line. There was a slight delay before the celebrations began as everyone waited for confirmation that he ball had crossed the line.
Barrow put Reading firmly in the driving seat with his first goal for his new club. A Kelly corner was helped on by Swift to Moore who found Barrow inside the six yard box to poke home. It was well a worked goal but raised questions about Villa’s defence for allowing Reading to pass the ball around their penalty area from a set piece.
McCleary, Evans and Beerens were given a run out as Villa appeared resigned to defeat allowing the Royals to indulge in some premature showboating. Blackett prevented Villa pulling a goal back in the seventy fourth minute with an outstanding tackle when Bjarnason looked certain to score. It was a remarkable piece of defending by any standard. Reading did not heed the warning and Villa did score with four minutes of normal time remaining. Agbonlahor, who was Villa’s most effective forward, chested the ball down for Hourihane to drive home from close range. By then many Villa fans had already left the ground and although Reading fans twitched nervously in their seats the victory deservedly came after four minutes of stoppage time.
Villa can have no complaints about the result.
Reading will feel they should have had the game sewn up long before the late Villa strike. Jaap Stam made it very clear he needs another striker, which was clear for all to see this evening.
John Wells
Post Match Fans' Opinion
John Madejski's Wallet
» 15 Aug 2017 22:24
Chalk and cheese from Saturday. Fast, incisive passing.
Clement, Swift, Kelly looked like a really dangerous trio
The less said about the weird subs (Beerens when you're trying to hold a lead FFS!), and switching off for the goal (nearly two) the better.
keep that up and we'll have a fun season
PieEater
» 15 Aug 2017 22:29
I didn't know we had goal line technology but then spotted the new camera at the top of Y25, in real time it look like a save but from the replay it looked way in. Pleased for Barrow to get a goal, I think we was probably MOTM before tiring in the second half.
Really surprised how poor Villa were, if you didn't know their players you'd worry about relegation, they were really that poor and most of the team looked like they didn't want to be there, despite some decent support from a full away end. Only Green looked decent, but he missed their best chance after a couple of mins. Their goal late on was well worked, nice lay off and put away nicely, not much Manone could do about that.
They've also sorted out the F1 buses so they go straight out - topped off a gr8 night
Roll on Preston
JR
» 15 Aug 2017 22:37
First game of the season for me, so lack some comparison to the QPR and Fulham performances, but we were terrific tonight.
A lot of people saying Villa were terrible on the match thread, but whilst that may be to some extent true that was largely because we bossed them and were hungrier with much more quality.
First half was comfortable and dominated - possession stats at one point were incredible - without creating too much clear cut and grateful that there striker fluffed his lines when our somewhat typical once a game back line clanger invited them in.
Second half we came out a different animal - extra edge and desire and the two goals were fully deserved in the first 15 minutes. The second goal was of the highest quality - a set piece that if it was Barcelona and MSN that delivered it then the world would be purring.
We then enjoyed twenty minutes or so of comfortable playful dominance and despite the late lapse that made it unnecessarily nerve wracking (but even more satisfying at the end) this was a thoroughly deserved win.
MoM for me was Barrow - but good performances all over and Mannone gave me great comfort with his confidence and speed on the ball.
When we bring in Oliveria later in the month we will have a squad that will compete right at the top of this division.
John Madejski's Wallet
» 15 Aug 2017 22:41
Barrow was tenacious and really impressed by his tracking back and tackling. He's like the anti-Beerens.
Have to admit to being worried for parts of the first half as we were getting up the wings but literally had no-one in the box. Wore them down in the end though.
Not sure if Villa were rubbish or we just played them into submission. Bit of both I guess
Crowbar6753
» 15 Aug 2017 22:44
Preston will be tough but i would take 4 points from them and Barnsley
Crowbar6753
» 15 Aug 2017 22:51
Royality creeps In
» 15 Aug 2017 22:58
A much better performance with 67% possession.
Swift played Well, Van den Berg was much improved from his cameo Saturday and McShane a rock. Having said that everyone put in a shift in tonight and even the wally's on this site will have trouble finding fault in the team this evening..
When I saw the line up without a striker I was concerned. I suppose I must put my faith in Stam because his tactics worked..
On another note, great support from Villa. They deserve better than the rubbish team that turned up tonight. I have seen all four games so far and Gillingham put up a better performance than them.
Gunny Fishcake
» 15 Aug 2017 23:14
NewCorkSeth
» 15 Aug 2017 23:19
Tactics were fantastic. Hopefully a taste of what our game plan will be throughout the season.
Make no mistake that was not a full strength team. If our squad players are able to produce displays like that it should not only allow us more impressive sub options during games but should also give Stam something to think about.
Our movement of the ball was crisp and clean throughout the pitch. The only criticism I would make is given the pace of some of our forward players we dawdled on the ball at times allowing the opposition too much time to reform. Kelly and Swift were most guilty of this which follows as they were the players asked to move the ball around most. JvdB drove forward much more but often visibly gesticulated at his teammates to get into positions. While his movement on the ball was more threatening I have a suspicion his teammates were not prepared for such movements. Perhaps it wasn't our tactics and he was doing his own thing.
Villa were woeful. Unable to control the midfield when in possession.
Defensively we were confident. McShane again had a miscommunication with Mannone. They spoke after and McShane made it clear, by the looks of it, what Mannones responsibilities are.
Mannone: Very assured with the ball at his feet. Confident under pressure. 2 (?) Very good saves. I'm confident in him as things stand! - 7.5
Gunter: Again much more dangerous when further up the pitch. Solid display. - 7/10
McShane: Has been commanding thus far. No complaints. - 7/10
Moore: He's top quality. Amazed we have him. - 7/10
Blackett: I feel harsh but again he made some minor errors. The cross for the goal was a result of his confusion over who to defend. - 6/10
JvdB: pashun defined. Mislayed 3 passes in the first 20 minutes. His drives forward threatened often. Harried the opposition fantasticly. - 7/10
Kelly: He's consistent. Move the ball well mostly. Understands our tactics very well and is becoming the driving force behind our team. - 7/10
Swift: Best performance thus far from him. With a proper forward he would have been a real danger. - 7/10
Barrow: Looks like a gem. He's quick and clever on the ball. Glad he scored. Motm. - 8/10
Popa: He works hard but was the least effective of our forwards. I often lost track of what he was doing. Fairly decent shot in the first half which forced a good save. - 7/10
Clement: It was almost his day. Took a fair few shots and was moving up and down the pitch well and got in much better positions than he managed against Fulham. - 7/10
Subs:
Evans: N/A
Beerens: N/A
McCleary: He's such a great player. 2 silly fouls. Best cross we've managed thus far came from him. Shame Clement can't jump. - 6/10
Ref was good.
genome
» 15 Aug 2017 23:21
Yeah. They looked utterly shit, but that's mostly because they let our best players play, and had no answer to Stam's tactics. There were a lot more runs off the ball from our players today, and it worked a treat. Quicker, more incisive, more adventurous. Swift and Barrow were excellent, and Popa and Clement deserve plaudits too. I think we were a striker away from properly thrashing them, which is a really good sign.
On the subject of Villa, they had a poor setup IMO. A decent scout would've identified the best way of countering our tactics would be to sit in deep, or press us high. They did neither. Even the Villa fans were screaming at their players to put pressure on our defence in the first half, I was baffled that it took Bruce until well into the second half to figure it out. Where was their midfield? Swift and Kelly were just bypassing it. The only player who looked like he gave a shit was Onomah and he's not even their player.
RE: JVDB, better today, but he still looked a liability at times in the first half. He makes me nervous.
NewCorkSeth
» 15 Aug 2017 23:26
Yeah. They looked utterly shit, but that's mostly because they let our best players play, and had no answer to Stam's tactics. There were a lot more runs off the ball from our players today, and it worked a treat. Quicker, more incisive, more adventurous. Swift and Barrow were excellent, and Popa and Clement deserve plaudits too. I think we were a striker away from properly thrashing them, which is a really good sign.
On the subject of Villa, they had a poor setup IMO. A decent scout would've identified the best way of countering our tactics would be to sit in deep, or press us high. They did neither. Even the Villa fans were screaming at their players to put pressure on our defence in the first half, I was baffled that it took Bruce until well into the second half to figure it out. Where was their midfield? Swift and Kelly were just bypassing it. The only player who looked like he gave a shit was Onomah and he's not even their player.
RE: JVDB, better today, but he still looked a liability at times in the first half. He makes me nervous.
Onomah looked great! Thought he played very well.
marlowuk
» 16 Aug 2017 03:13
Hound
» 16 Aug 2017 06:52
However we were very good. 2-1 really didn't do it justice
Our passing was much slicker than last year - some really nice pinging into feet. New pitch obv helps that. Swift back to his best, Mannone looks a good buy, Barrow could be bargain of the season - what a performance from him
Loads of options on the bench, McCleary looked very threatening up top in his cameo. Still top players coming back to fitness
Things looking up...
bobby1413
» 16 Aug 2017 07:17
Agreed, I think we ran complete circles around them. Last year it was like we were doing it but with no purpose, more flaky, a bit unsure, plus AAH (who I love) was not as good as Vito at controlling the ball and distributing it back out. I am completely confident and happy watching Vito do this, where as with AAH I was completely on edge.
May be a whooooosh - but is this close to happening? wasn't sure if it was one of those rumours that won't ever happen or if it does look like we're close to a deal
RoyalBlue
» 16 Aug 2017 07:25
There were times when we looked really good. Yes, Villa looked poor but, as Gooding said, that was because we made them look poor.
If we can sign a proven goalscorer we are going to hammer some teams and do really well this season. I see little prospect of us 'sneaking in under the radar' this time around. The media are going to have no choice but to sit up and take notice, and I think they are going to like what they see.
Oh, and the night was made even more enjoyable because the moaning git who sits behind me in Y21 and spends the whole game abusing our players and management decided to take the night off - hopefully boycotting in disgust at Stam's refusal to revert to Neanderthal football. Long may that boycott continue!
Match Stats
Full Time: 2-1
Half Time: 0-0
Attendance: 20144
Referee: K Friend
[More]
Teams
Reading:
V Mannone, T Blackett, C Gunter, P McShane, L Moore, A Popa (G McCleary, 70), J Swift, M Barrow (R Beerens, 77), J van den Berg (G Evans, 70), L Kelly, P Clement.
Subs not used: T Ilori, J Mendes, A Jaakkola, L Bacuna.
Aston Villa:
S Johnstone, J Chester, R de Laet (A Hutton, 63), N Taylor, J Terry, B Bjarnason, A Green, C Hourihane, G Whelan, S Hogan (G Agbonlahor, 29), J Onomah (A Adomah, 77).
Subs not used: C Samba, H Lansbury, J Bree, J Steer.
Bookings / Red Cards
Reading: L Moore, G McCleary
Aston Villa: A Green, C Hourihane
Championship on 15 August 2017
This Championship game took place 3139 days ago in the 2017/2018 season.

