Reading FC Match Report: 2016/2017 Season - Championship
READING 1 ASTON VILLA 2
Reading: Y Kermorgant (54).
Aston Villa: J Kodjia (38), J Ayew (pen 90).
A last minute penalty ended the Royals’ unbeaten home run this season, and provided Villa with their first away win in fourteen months. The statistics prior to this game pointed to a home win but, Tim Dellor please note, statistics are of little value in predicting the outcome of football matches. The arrival of Steve Bruce clearly gave the visitors a lift, but also they have one of the strongest squads in the Championship and will surely be challenging for promotion by the end of the season.
In spite of dominating possession once again Reading were unable to convert that dominance into goals. Villa scored against the run of play just before half time with a somewhat fortunate deflected strike credited to Kodjia. Reading equalised early in the second half through Kermorgant which seemed prompt Villa to raise their game. Having sat back in the first half they changed tactics and pressed Reading higher up the pitch forcing them to play a greater percentage of long balls. The game became more open with Reading exploiting the space which opened up as Villa pushed forward. Ultimately Villa had more of a cutting edge refreshing their attack with Amavi and Ayew. As Reading tired and looked increasingly likely to win the game. In the last minute Ayew took a tumble over Moore’s outstretched leg and Andy Woolmer awarded his second penalty of the night. Ayew stroked the ball past Al Habsi with supreme confidence to send the 4000 travelling Villa fans into delirious celebration.
Reading fielded the same starting eleven as on Saturday at Loftus Road. Villa seemed content to sit back and allow Reading to play in front of their defensive shield and wait for their chance to hit Reading on the break. It worked perfectly for them restricting Reading to a couple of hopeful strikes on goal that did not trouble ‘keeper Gollini. Reading’s build up was impressive at times with some superbly struck long range passes into wide positions. There was also a greater willingness to play balls in to the space behind the Villa back line. Sadly nothing came of their good work. Villa exploited the space behind Gunter to mount an attack which ended with Kodjia giving them the lead when his shot took a huge deflection off Blackett to deceive Al Habsi.
Early in the second half Beerens knocked a brilliant ball over the Villa defence to provide McCleary with a run on goal. Cissokho brought his run to an end with a foul in the box. Williams’ spot kick was blocked by Gollini but Kermorgant was following up and headed firmly over the grounded ‘keeper for the equaliser. The visitors were stung in to action by the goal and went looking for the winner. The game became more open and chances began to open up at either end. Urged on by their fans Villa put the Reading back four and Al Habsi under pressure at every opportunity. The Reading ‘keeper looked particularly vulnerable although Reading to their credit stuck to their game plan. Evans hit a good shot which Gollini always looked likely to save. Kermorgant got his head to a couple of crosses without generating sufficient power to test the ‘keeper. Perhaps if Jaap Stam had introduced a couple of substitutes they may have coped better with the threat posed by a rejuvenated Villa attack. Reading began to look weary and gaps began to appear at the back. The pace of Hutton and Adomah was giving Blackett a torrid time and Beerens was not able to offer much protection. Ayew came on for last fifteen minutes and caused sufficient panic to win the crucial penalty. McCleary fired a shot past the post in stoppage time but Villa held on for a very important win for them. For Reading it was disappointing end to frustrating evening.
John Wells
Post Match Fans' Opinion
LWJ
» 19 Oct 2016 12:12
Think we deserved a point Villa looked like they came for one and set up 4-5-1 to try get us on the counter. Which is where their first goal came from.
In the 2nd half they got told to press us more evidently which made us be careless in possession. This seems like a common trend this year, 1st half we dominate without creating any clear cut chances, 2nd half teams are given a kick up the backside and we create our own problems.
Stam needs to utilise his subs, though listening to his interview on BBC Berks gave me the impression he doesn't rate Samuel and the only reason he is on the bench is that every other option is injured.
As long as we improve on our league position from last year, we are making progress. So I will continue to support the team, and the style of play. 2 losses in 11 games don't suggest we should panic just yet.
Pandoras Box
» 19 Oct 2016 12:51
Being pedantic this is not necessarily true.
If other teams are shittier than they were last year our position could improve, but our play could be the same or worse?
That isn't really progress.
Just saying like.
LWJ
» 19 Oct 2016 12:57
Table end of last year:
Reading - Currently 10th
Bristol City - Currently 6th
Huddersfield - Currently 4th
Fulham - Currently 11th
Rotherham - Currently 24th
Charlton - Replaced by Wigan currently 22nd
MK Dons - Replaced by Barnsley currently 14th
Bolton - Replaced by Burton Albion currently 18th
Looks to me like the teams below us have improved. Or have every other team in the Championship got a lot worse?
ladida_gunner_graham
» 19 Oct 2016 14:26
Positives
Liam Moore looks solid, skillful and an excellent buy. Love him.
Villa fans were respectful and really impressive.
Kingsley seems to have lost a few pounds.
Negatives
Beerens needs to start putting in some performances. Did virtually nothing, amazed he didn't get subbed.
Not at all sure that Stam knows how to change a game with his bench. No evidence to date.
Gunter was atrocious, can't possibly be that bad again. Ever.
Williams simply has no idea how to make himself available as an option for the defence to pass to. If you disagree, watch him for the next few games. It's almost like he's hiding. Watch him take up impossible to hit positions, then wildly gesticulate for the ball and feign disappointment when he doesn't get it. We've seen you Danny and your gig is up.
bobby1413
» 19 Oct 2016 15:46
There were times when instead of clearing they passed to keeper and then played it around the back, very nearly losing possession. We are definitely going to concede from an error in this at some point.
Blackett ... He's not good enough, and certainly not good enough to be trying tricks against oncoming strikers.
I don't know our possession % but it must be high again, there were times when it was non stop reading attack. However with very little product.
Didn't see the villa pen so not sure if it was fair or not.
I've seen us play worse tbh, and I don't think we did that badly. We had a fair number of shots, and some decent chances. But as we all know we just don't have any lethal striking options.
That said, credit to kermorgant as I thought he worked his socks off
Am I right in thinking we didn't make any subs until 85+ minute?
Hampshire Royal
» 19 Oct 2016 16:07
In the second half, we played well in midfield and on the wings, but just didn't have anyone who could take advantage of this.
I'm sure that Stam is aware of this, and is now looking for a good striker like Forster or Cureton.
I've got no problem with our possession football, and I didn't think we passed back to AAH as often as we have in other games.
We all knew that this season would be a work-in-process, and we maybe thought we would be worse off than we are now, but I'm convinced that it is all coming together, and we will see something good come from this. Not this season, maybe, but certainly next!!
At least we're not Villa who've spent 50+ million on players. Terrific fans, though, bearing in mind they've had two or three years of absolute dross.
Lower West
» 19 Oct 2016 16:12
Stam is constrained by what's available to him and the lack of experience within the team. We are heading in the right direction. This year will a series of ups and downs. Not good enough for promotion but far better than we've been in the past few seasons.
Like to see Beerans play on the right. Looking forward to seeing Meite get a run out soon too. As should offer further options.
Sutekh
» 19 Oct 2016 17:18
Game was lost due to Stam's ineptitude with substitutions. Harriott should have replaced a rather tired looking Beerens after three quarters of the game. Also an appalling decision by the referee to give Villa a free kick on the halfway line just before they got their penalty cost us.
However we should have won it before then and probably would have done if the substitutions had been forthcoming.
Lastly, as ever we desperately need that striking option....
bloody Volvo driver
» 19 Oct 2016 17:29
Bruce did a job on us and our management was found wanting.
CountryRoyal
» 19 Oct 2016 17:57
That's not "doing a job" that's just organisation and discipline, to a very basic level at that.
You can be "patient" at the back all you like but for the vast majority of the game it will be easy to defend. The real skill is in retaining possession patiently and dragging defenders out of position in midfield and further, and we just don't do that enough.
Royality creeps In
» 19 Oct 2016 18:54
Its all very well playing this possession/passing stuff, however there is virtually no end product. Certainly not a lot of goal scoring opportunities.
If I recall correctly our penalty was from a hoof upfield that McCleary ran on to and was bundled over.
Once the opposition suss out our way of playing we are fuked!
AV were nothing special and looked a team short of confidence. We failed to take advantage and pile more misery on them due to our poor tactics.
Westwood52
» 19 Oct 2016 20:48
I actually thought we had the better of Villa over 90 minutes; but they found the will to go again in the last ten to fifteen minutes, enabling them to snatch undeserved win. Maybe Bruce deserves credit for being bold with his use of subs-while Stam kept his in the hutch-even though there were signs of real fatigue all over the place.
Al Habsi 4: Looked shaky all night & another clanger-you don't necessarily expect your goalie to save pens-but he did make it easy for the taker.
Gunts 4: OK 1st half; but dreadful in the 2nd;one of a number of wusses in hoops.
Moore 6: Because his defence was falling apart; was overstretched, almost from the off.
Joey 4:Dreadful passing and inept defending.
Blackett 5: Very poor 1st half;but TBF he became a lot more physical 2nd half-not really a wing back-must be better than Joey @CB.Give him time & he may prove a useful buy.
Evans 6: Neat and tidy as ever and one really good strike-needs to toughen up, but he is still a young lad.
Swift 6:As ever showed a lot of flair. But he seems to be caught in no mans land-unwilling to get nearer Kermit,but he's worried about Williams in midfield.
Williams 4: Oh dear-Quinny when fit has to be the better option.
Macca 7: Marginally our best player-but he became careless in the 2nd half;I assume fatigue was the cause.
Kermit 7: Worked hard as always;but just lacks sharpness.
Beerens 3: Why is he even on the teamsheet-Harriot must be terrible in training. Proving to be a disappointing buy.
Ref: We have had worse this season-but clearly not up to it.
Steve_Upper_West
» 19 Oct 2016 21:22
Ian Royal
» 19 Oct 2016 21:29
Anyone looked at our results by who scores first? I get the feeling we're really hard to beat, and usually win, if we take the lead... but really really struggle if we go behind. Because of our obvious lack of goals and slightly ponderous and uncertain build up.
...
Games we score first and in first half
P5, W4, D1, L0
Games we conceded first and in first half
P5, W0, D1, L4
Other
P3, W1, D2, L0
It's not exactly ground breaking, but if we take the lead before half time, we're very unlikely to lose and win 75% of the time. If we go behind before half time we very unlikely to win or draw. Don't concede in the first half and we're looking decent. So basically, we don't win from going behind still, which is because we're no good at taking the game to the opposition, but if we can establish a foothold, we're very very hard to beat.
3points
» 19 Oct 2016 21:49
Beerens is clearly a Stam favourite. Will he ever be dropped or subbed? The new Jobi McAnuff?
And why bring on Gravenberch to play centre forward rather than try Samuel for the last 5 minutes? Very strange.
John Madejski's Wallet
» 19 Oct 2016 23:55
Isn't that the exact same problem we've had under all our recent managers that have wanted to play possession football out from the back. It means a total lack of urgency when chasing a game and usually going out with a whimper. All too familiar since we dropped back down
Ian Royal
» 20 Oct 2016 00:16
Isn't that the exact same problem we've had under all our recent managers that have wanted to play possession football out from the back. It means a total lack of urgency when chasing a game and usually going out with a whimper. All too familiar since we dropped back down
I think the problems have been quite different and the different managers have had different approaches. It's not like there's only one type of possession football.
Adkins didn't get near the support of Clarke or Stam and was screwed by owners. His brand of passing football wasn't the same.
Clarke's certainly wasn't either. And McDermott got left with the shitty end of a stick.
Stam is the only one who seems to have had a clear vision and philosophy and plan to implement it from the start. He's brought in a defender to give us the opportunity to play from the back when historically we haven't really had that base. I don't really agree with the split the CB ethos, or Stam's system of having two such wide forwards supporting the striker. I prefer them narrower... the one thing I liked under Clarke.
There's clearly a goal issue, but Stam was never going to address everything in one window. I fear we may easily slip back into a funk and getting the right striker could be nigh impossible. But I don't think our problems now have the same causes at all, even if they may have the same symptom of lack of penetration and goals. But, it's much much easier being positive when I'm no longer wasting and entire day of my weekend to watch 90 minutes of dissapointment every other week.
I don't have the best view of the situation and I'm not trying to comment on individual games, just what I see, what people report and on results.
Sutekh
» 20 Oct 2016 10:00
Isn't that the exact same problem we've had under all our recent managers that have wanted to play possession football out from the back. It means a total lack of urgency when chasing a game and usually going out with a whimper. All too familiar since we dropped back down
Actually thought Stam had cracked that as after the usual drab, dull, insipid, going nowhere first half the players came out with much more drive and enthusiasm and purpose and more than matched Villa and should have won but for the usual lack of a goalscorer and lack of substitutions to replace obviously tired looking players.
Consequently feel a bit more upset about the team and prospects after that than the usual malaise that has been setting in after other performances.
muirinho
» 20 Oct 2016 10:20
The problem so far is that we don't play from the back we play at the back.
Sometimes we do, and sometimes we don't. Part of the problem is that in order to create space it requires very patient passing to create the space. If any of those passes are risky, the crowd gets restless, and sometimes that makes the players panicky, and they boot it forward when there's no space to pass it into. Or it's not risky at all, but it is boring, and the crowd gets restless, with similar results. So it fails. And other times, the final pass forward into space goes awry. Because, you know, we have a back 4 that is worth, tops £3 million. Not £30 million. And of course you have the problem that the midfield isn't very good always at finding that space. Especially Danny Williams (hey, if you can have Gunter as a permanent scapegoat, I can have Danny. )
I do think, seriously, that we are getting better at it. And the problem isn't the back 4, it's further up the pitch. But I'm kind of dreading Rotherham, because of the miserable run they've been on - it would be entirely predictable if we, yet again, are the catalysts for the breaking of a terrible run.
Match Stats
Full Time: 1-2
Half Time: 0-1
Attendance: 20331
Referee: A Woolmer
[More]
Teams
Reading:
A Al Habsi, T Blackett, L Moore, J van den Berg, C Gunter, G Evans (D Gravenberch, 89), G McCleary, J Swift, D Williams, R Beerens, Y Kermorgant.
Subs not used: C Harriott, D Samuel, T Watson, J Obita, L Kelly, A Jaakkola.
Aston Villa:
P Gollini, A Hutton, J Chester, A Cissokho (J Amavi, 77), N Baker, M Jedinak, L Bacuna, G Gardner, A Adomah, J Kodjia (R McCormack, 86), R Gestede (J Ayew, 77).
Subs not used: A Westwood, A Tshibola, A Green, M Bunn.
Bookings / Red Cards
Reading: G McCleary
Aston Villa: A Hutton
This Championship game took place 3439 days ago in the 2016/2017 season.

